Yoshimitsu Morita's 'Haru' (1996)
Her Head in FilmsOctober 26, 202601:27:35

Yoshimitsu Morita's 'Haru' (1996)

In this episode, I talk about Yoshimitsu Morita's 1996 film, "Haru." Set during the early days of the internet, the film follows Haru and Hoshi, two strangers who meet in an online film chat room and begin corresponding privately through email. They don’t know what the other looks like and initially know very little about each other’s lives, but through the act of writing to each other they gradually form a bond that becomes deeply important to both of them.

I talk about "Haru" as a time capsule of what the internet once was and perhaps what it might never be again. I also explore the intimacy of connecting through words, the meaning of friendship, and the way connection can awaken us and draw us back toward life after loss. There are spoilers in this episode.

If you’d like to support my work and get access to bonus episodes and exclusive posts, you can join me on Patreon: patreon.com/herheadinfilmspodcast.

You can follow me on Letterboxd. My email is herheadinfilms@gmail.com.

My Sources:

[00:00:19] Hello! Welcome to another episode of Her Head in Films. I'm Caitlin and I'm your host. On this podcast, I share my thoughts and feelings about the films I watch. They tend to be art house and world cinema. What makes this podcast unique is that I weave together my life experiences with a personal and emotional discussion of film. I explore the impact that cinema has on me and why I connect so deeply to it. As I like to say, my head isn't in the clouds, my head is in films.

[00:00:49] If the podcast resonates with you and you want to help it thrive, Patreon is where I'm building a more connected space for listeners, offering bonus episodes, extra posts, and a direct way to show support for the work I'm doing here. If you want to be part of that community, join me at patreon.com slash Her Head in Films podcast. And as always, leaving a review or a rating or helping spread the word is appreciated.

[00:01:14] In today's episode, I'm talking about Yoshimitsu Morita's 1996 film Haru. Set during the early days of the internet, the film follows Haru and Hoshi, two strangers who meet in an online film chat room and begin corresponding privately through email.

[00:01:32] They don't know what the other looks like, and initially they know very little about each other's lives. But through the act of writing to each other, they gradually form a bond that becomes deeply important to both of them. I talk about Haru as a time capsule of what the internet once was and perhaps what it might never be again. I also explore the intimacy of connecting through words, the meaning of friendship, and the way connection can awaken us and draw us back toward life after loss.

[00:02:01] There are spoilers in this episode. I really adore this film. I know a lot of people probably will not know about it. It's not necessarily streaming, but there are ways that you can probably find it online. I wanted to talk about this film for multiple reasons. I think it is a film for the sensitive and the tender-hearted people of the world.

[00:02:26] I think if you're someone who loves books and loves writing and believes very intensely in not just connecting with other people, but the medium through which you can connect to others. If you believe that you can connect through writing and language and words, through emails, messages, letters, I think that the film will speak to you. As I said, there are spoilers in this episode, and I know I'm taking a little bit of a chance to talk about a film

[00:02:55] that's not widely available on streaming services, but I hope that if you end up watching the film because of this episode, and that's always what I wish, is that the people who follow me or listen to these episodes, if I talk about a film that's more obscure or lesser known, that is me giving other people a nudge and wanting to inspire them to seek the film out and to maybe have their own experience with it.

[00:03:22] I watched this a few years ago in 2023, and now I'm doing an episode in 2026, and it was so special. When I went back to it to do this episode, I was crying by the end of it, and I don't know if I cried the first time that I watched it, but it really touched me. I am a very nostalgic person. I'm in my late 30s. I grew up in the 90s and the 2000s. I remember that time.

[00:03:49] This film evokes that period, of course, and there's also something very warm and optimistic about it as well in the way that it looks at two people using digital technology to connect with each other. Social media and the internet have changed drastically since about 2020 with the pandemic and the rise of short-form content, particularly video,

[00:04:16] and I found myself drawn back to this film as a way to talk about connection, but also to talk about the modern world that we're living in, where it feels harder to find connection through the digital world. The internet used to be such a different space, and I'll be talking about that throughout this episode, and I don't want it to become a negative episode. I don't want to go on and on about the way things have changed

[00:04:43] or the way that I feel they've deteriorated, but that is part of what makes this film very special. As I said in my introduction, it's a time capsule, and it captures a more optimistic, perhaps, time when it came to the internet. This film also has similarities with You've Got Mail by Nora Ephron, but You've Got Mail came out a few years later. I have no idea if Nora Ephron came across Haru or saw it,

[00:05:13] or I'm not sure if there's any kind of relationship between the films directly, and I actually re-watched You've Got Mail before re-watching Haru for this episode because I enjoy re-watching You've Got Mail just about every year. It's a film that comforts me, and I really love Nora Ephron, but something that occurred to me as I was watching You've Got Mail, and it would also relate to my experience of going back to Haru,

[00:05:40] is that I realized how drastically different the internet is. The thing is, is that both of these films capture a time when the internet was not a space where we performed ourselves. Social media has created a space where there's performance. There's a layer of artifice, and particularly with the shift to video and it being so image-based and video-based at this point,

[00:06:06] we forget maybe that there was a time when the internet was more private, was smaller, was made of these little forums and chat rooms, and it wasn't as visual. And so when you were talking to somebody, you didn't necessarily know what they looked like. You did not know much about their embodied life at all. And so there were people who gravitated to the internet. I was one of them in around 2010. That's when I got online on Tumblr.

[00:06:35] There were people who were drawn to the internet as a form of escape and as a way to maybe be liberated from the body, to maybe find other kindred spirits or like-minded souls, and to connect more through language and writing. That's what we see in Haru and You've Got Mail. These are not people performing for each other. These are not people pretending to be something that they're not. Although I would say that Haru,

[00:07:04] there's some things he's not fully honest about, so that complicates it a little bit. Instead of performing themselves, what they actually do is that they reveal parts of themselves that they cannot reveal in daily life. That was the attraction for me personally when I got online. I struggled. I grew up in the rural South and I never felt like I belonged. I wasn't religious. I wasn't conservative. I couldn't find my people.

[00:07:33] I couldn't find places where I belonged. And I always just felt out of step and disconnected from the world around me. And when I got online, I felt kind of this freedom or this excitement or this sense of like escaping the regular world and being able to go online. But I didn't want to go online and pretend to be somebody else. I actually wanted to be more myself because I was very like cerebral and literary. I loved books.

[00:08:02] And obviously I love cinema and I love art. And I wanted a space where I could share my passions. And that's what I do on this podcast. I've never felt like I was pretending to be somebody. I've never tried to perform. And I've never branded myself as some kind of content creator or authority on cinema. I am not trying to be anybody other than myself. And that is very hard for me to do in daily life

[00:08:30] where I feel like I have to wear a mask and I have to pretend. And I think we see that a little bit, particularly with Hoshi, where she feels like the internet is a space that she can escape into. And I'll talk about that as the episode goes on. So there are people who in the early days of the internet in like the 90s, they were going online. And I'm not saying everybody, but I think for these two characters,

[00:08:57] something more authentic and honest and vulnerable comes out in their emails to each other. It was like a reminder to me of, in some ways, what we have lost. I'm not saying that you can't find pockets of it. I'm sure you can. There's Discord and there's different forums. And some of that internet still exists. And I'm not going to deny that. But I've definitely noticed a stark difference in the ability to connect with other people online the last few years.

[00:09:27] I think it's just difficult. I think people are going to the internet for different reasons now. It's become much more about entertainment and the short form content. I miss when there was this feeling of I could be more myself online. I can share these hidden parts of myself with another person through the screen. And it did feel like the screen could be a site of connection.

[00:09:53] And now I feel like with the algorithms and all the advertising and the rise of AI and chatbots, I feel like more and more things are separating us from each other and fracturing us. And I myself have retreated. And I've actually left the internet almost completely for the most part. It's just interesting because like 16 years ago, I came online and I felt a sense of freedom and possibility.

[00:10:22] And now I've had to retreat from that space. And there's a grieving that has happened for me. There's something mournful about it. To watch something that had so much promise. And we see that in Haru. And I think the film captures that. And again, I'm not saying it's impossible. I actually have several online friends who have been profoundly important to my life. And who helped me through the death of my mother last year.

[00:10:49] So I am not saying that online connection is impossible in this day and age. It's not impossible. But I think it's harder. And I think it's more complicated. I see things happening online that are fracturing us. That are not bringing us together. Or they're making it harder to connect with other people. I think those of us who wanted to be more ourselves or more authentic, I'm just very turned off by all of the changes that I see.

[00:11:17] And I realize these spaces are not right for me. They're not the right format for me to express myself. It's why I've held on to the podcast. It's one of the reasons why I've held on to this podcast. It's because I still feel like this is a direct channel to other people. And to the outside world. Where I can speak how I want. And I can be who I truly am. And I can say the words that I want to say. So I do believe that language can connect us.

[00:11:47] I do believe that we can connect through a screen. And I want to make that clear. But I think that the internet has just drastically changed. And I also believe that at some point, the embodiment does have to come into it. Or it needs to come into it. We can't live online forever, right? What's so interesting about Haru is at the end, they don't leave it just as usernames floating in the ether of the internet.

[00:12:16] They want to meet each other in real life. They want to go toward embodiment. And to see each other face to face. The connection that's forged online is important. But there needs to be that deeper engagement in the real world. And I think we are seeing pockets of resistance. I think we're seeing more people go back to the tangible, the analog. They want to get off social media. They don't want to have things fed to them through algorithms.

[00:12:45] They don't want to take in a bunch of propaganda. They don't want to be so like colonized by it and have their attention taken from them. And that's all we can do is maybe do our own forms of resistance against it. And a form of resistance is to actually connect with other people, to meet face to face, to go toward that embodiment and that community and caring about each other in real life as well. Online connection can be so important.

[00:13:13] And I've lived that. But I think a lot of people are rebelling or some people are rebelling against what's happening on the internet. And Haru is a reminder to us of the way it once was and how it could have continued. And it actually could have gotten even better. And instead, the wrong people got power. The wrong people took control. I doubt it will ever be like that again. But at least we have this time capsule. And that's what I want to talk about in this episode.

[00:13:42] I'm excited to talk about the film. I want to give like some basic information about the cast and about Yoshimitsu Morita. Then I'm going to talk about my thoughts and feelings and everything about the film. And I hope that that's valuable. The film came out in 1996. Our cast is pretty much two people that I'm going to focus on in this episode. We have Eri Fukatsu as Hoshi. Hoshi is her screen name.

[00:14:10] And then her actual name, Mitsue Fujima. And then as Haru, the man that she is emailing with, we have Masaki Uchino. Haru is his screen name. But his real name is Noboru Hayami. And Sayo Uchino is credited as Masaki Uchino in the film. So he changed his name some years ago. It's a simple film in a lot of ways.

[00:14:38] Like there's not a ton of plot going on. That's what makes it so special and unique, I think, is that it's an intimate film in that way where we get to enter into the correspondence between these two people who can't see each other and who only know each other through the gradual revealing of themselves, the daily details of their lives. There's an intimacy that grows out of the medium of email. And it's really fascinating to watch it.

[00:15:07] I did want to give a little bit of information about Yoshimitsu Morita. There's not a lot out there. I apologize. Usually with my episodes, I have more behind the scenes information about a film. This was very difficult. This film was very difficult to research. Most of the sources were in Japanese, of course. So I had to translate it to English at times. Morita was born in 1950 and he died in 2011.

[00:15:36] His filmmaking career spanned three decades. He was mostly a self-taught filmmaker. He started experimenting in the 1970s. His first feature film came out in 1981 called Something Like It. A huge breakthrough for him was the 1983 film The Family Game. This is a dark comedy about a Japanese family who hires a tutor to help their son.

[00:16:02] So this film became one of his best known works and it did establish him as an important contemporary Japanese filmmaker. And one of the things that stands out about him is that he did not confine himself to one genre. He has comedies, horror, melodrama, crime films. There's a lot of variety in his body of work.

[00:16:27] Haru came out of his genuine interest in the new technology of the internet. Personal computers were starting to become a bit more popular in Japan at that time. People had computers. Now, I grew up in the 90s and 2000s, but I actually didn't grow up with a computer in my own home. You know, computers weren't necessarily everywhere, at least here in the US, but I don't quite know how it was in Japan in the 90s.

[00:16:54] But he was genuinely interested in this technology and he wanted to explore that through Haru. He incorporates the words that Hoshi and Haru are writing to each other or typing to each other. He includes that in the film itself. You see it on the screen. And so Film at Lincoln Center noted that he wanted that on-screen text to almost be like a character in and of itself. I think that it definitely functions that way.

[00:17:24] Now, I want to go through the film and talk about different things. Sometimes I'll go through a film like scene by scene or chronologically. But for this film, I really want to talk about specific themes. So a big reason why I was drawn back to the film is that it is a time capsule of the early internet. And it's a time capsule of the 1990s itself. The fashion and the interiors.

[00:17:50] When I was watching it again, and when I watched it the first time, it gave me such a cozy feeling. This is a cozy film for me personally. And like I said, by the end of it, I was crying. It hit all the perfect notes for me, for the most part. You know, the fashion, the 90s aesthetic, the warmth of it. Two people connecting through the written word was just made for me as a writer, as someone who loves books and language.

[00:18:19] I think I do believe that that's possible. And we don't have a lot of films that really explore that. That explore in-depth messages being written between two people. For me, it's very unique in that way, in terms of all of the films that I've seen. So it's a time capsule of the early internet in the 90s. We have the dial-up sounds. We have the desktop computers that are large.

[00:18:47] And they take up a lot of room. Email, chat rooms, camcorders. The internet is more tangible than I think it is now. And many people have talked about this online. But, you know, I was there and I lived it. And a lot of other people my age who are millennials lived it as well. The internet was a room. It was, you know, people had a computer room in their house.

[00:19:15] You know, one room where the computer was on a desk. Or when you were in school, if you didn't have a computer where you lived at home, there was a computer lab. I remember the computer lab, you know, in elementary school and high school. The internet was physically located somewhere. And there was a demarcation and a boundary between you and that world. And that is something that has been lost. Now we have the internet in our pockets on our smartphones.

[00:19:44] It is omnipresent. It suffuses the world we live in. And it is inescapable. And that does something to us psychologically. Haru reminds us of a time when you had your real life and then you would go online. And this was something that was interesting to me as I watched the film, is that that's what the film shows us. So we see Hoshi and Haru living their separate lives.

[00:20:12] We see Haru playing football. We see him working his job. We see him with his girlfriend who eventually breaks up with him. We see him as an embodied person. And we see him in a way that Hoshi cannot see him as she's emailing with him at first. And it's the same for her. We see her working at the bakery or in the opening scene or one of the opening scenes. I think we just see her at a gas station just looking through a window.

[00:20:38] Hoshi in particular, there's like a solitude about her life. And we often see her alone. And she talks about how she feels separate from other people. And so she's often shown just kind of sitting by herself. Or we see her in the room with the computer right at her home where she lives with the bookcases behind her. And we see her in her everyday embodied reality.

[00:21:04] And then we see the text, the emails that are going between Hoshi and Haru. And it's this reminder of the boundary between the two worlds. That there's Hoshi at her job at the bakery. There's Haru playing football, right? It's their daily existence. And then they sit down to the computer and they write about what they've just lived. They write about what just happened.

[00:21:32] But they're not living on the computer. They're not living through a screen. They're connecting through the screen, but they're not living on it. And I think that's been a shift, right? For a while now of living through the screen where we can never escape it. And there feels like there is no separation between us and the screen. But I am someone who like I'm trying to resist that. I was on social media like everybody else for a long time.

[00:22:01] For 15 some years. And then I saw changes on it and I decided I needed to get off of it. That it was too all-consuming. And it is worrisome how we're not really resisting it as much as I think we probably should. And so it was nice. It was nice to see when life was like that. It was nice to be reminded of that. And like why couldn't it have stayed that way? You know, there are great things about the internet.

[00:22:28] Being able to order things and it's made life easier in some ways. And then it's also brought a lot of negative things as well. So I love like the aesthetics of the film. The desktop computer, the bookshelves, the CDs and CD-ROMs. It's like now there's no separation between the two worlds. It's easier to just get lost online because it's right there in your hand. You don't have to go to a desk and sit there.

[00:22:58] It's right there in bed with you. It's like, and I think that also changes how we connect with people through it. There's this feeling of, well, you need to be available 24-7. And texting can create an unearned intimacy, I would say. When you are texting with someone constantly or immediately in real time, I believe that can form an attachment. And it can create an intimacy with someone who you may not know very well. With email, email is a slower form of communication.

[00:23:28] And we see that between Haru and Hoshi where it's gradual. The intimacy perhaps is more earned. When they start talking about, you know, when she says near the end after the video, I'll treasure this video. You know, talking to you has really made a difference in my life. All these things. She didn't say that after the first email. It's an intimacy and a connection that has been earned over quite a few months over talking

[00:23:55] to each other, something gradually unfolding rather than something being immediate. My experience of the internet, and I'm really glad that I had it when I was about 20 and I got on Tumblr in 2010. My early experience of the internet was rooted in blogging, in forums, in text, right? In reading other people's blogs, finding people through shared interests.

[00:24:21] It wasn't based on video or selfies or things like that. It was based more on the words of other people and connecting through that medium. And that's what we see in Haru. It's two people really connecting through text on the screen. And we see that text ourselves. We don't just hear them saying the words or something.

[00:24:47] We are seeing the words, reading the words ourselves, the way that they're reading each other's words. And I'm really glad that I had the experience that I had at those early stages because it gives me a comparison point, doesn't it? Now, things are dominated by feeds, algorithms, photos, short form video, influencers, shopping, advertising.

[00:25:12] Yeah, there were ads on old websites and blogger accounts and all of that, of course. But it just was not the way that it is now. For me, the internet has become like a big shopping mall. Like social media has particularly become like this, very commercialized. We're constantly being sold something under the guise of this. Like we're told that social media is social, right? We're told that this is how you connect with others. But I don't buy that anymore.

[00:25:42] I don't think that this is connecting us for the most part. We have less control over what we are shown. That's what the algorithms have started to do. We're starting to be fed things. That was not real. Like when I started out, you chose who to follow. And then you had a feed that was chronological of people that you had chosen to follow and whose blogs you wanted to read or whose thoughts you wanted to read.

[00:26:09] And that's so drastically different from what we have now. The volume has exploded. That's also what moved me about this film is that it's two people connecting with each other. It's one-on-one, whereas now there's more parasocial stuff happening online. People might follow hundreds or thousands of people, right? It's much harder to establish that one-on-one type of connection with another person.

[00:26:39] It's been hard for me. I mean, I've had this podcast for 10 years and you would think that I would have made friends through it, wouldn't you? You would think that I met other cinephiles and I have not been able to do that. And I have no idea why. I basically have like very few people that I have like connected to and formed durable friendships through this podcast. It is not for a lack of trying.

[00:27:06] I'm not quite sure why I've struggled to actually connect with people through film or through this podcast. I wish it's such a mystery to me and I've tried and I've given it my all and now I have just stopped and I've just left social media and I don't want to be a part of it anymore. It's been a strange phenomenon for me and I don't quite know the answer to it.

[00:27:31] So I really have been mourning what has happened online and I'm still glad that I watched this. It can be a little bit painful to remember when something was better, right? But it actually left me at the end feeling like, okay, I feel like my faith is restored a little bit. Even though it's been hard for me to connect online for a while now and I don't know why, that doesn't mean that it can't still happen. It's still possible.

[00:28:00] I think the film reminds us of that, that there can be a genuine, authentic connection with other people. It might be harder, but what we see in the film is that we see two people discovering each other. We see two strangers meeting in a chat room and then ending up really close friends and possibly more. It's up in the air at the end of the film, isn't it? And they just start to write these emails and they become very important to each other.

[00:28:29] This is something I'll talk about when I get into my section about friendship. It is mysterious how we find each other, isn't it? How somebody goes from a stranger or just a random username and then they become your best friend, right? There are all kinds of people who meet online and then meet in real life and it does go into the real world or it becomes like a really great connection that lasts for many years.

[00:28:56] And somebody who was a stranger becomes a beloved friend and sometimes more. I mean, there are people who fall in love, right? There are people who start out on Instagram or Twitter or whatever and end up married. It still happens. It happens all the time. I don't want to just throw out internet connection. I'm not someone who thinks in a very black and white way. But for me personally, I have for years now struggled with connecting with people and I've

[00:29:25] watched things just drastically change on these platforms into a point where I can't be on them, you know? And I remember a time like what is in Haru. I remember that feeling of possibility of getting to know another person in a deep and meaningful way through writing to each other. That's how some of my online friendships have started. Or I guess all of them started that way, right? I know it's possible. It's rare.

[00:29:51] It's rare and it takes two people fully on the same page, open to each other and mattering to each other and being important to each other. The film shows a mutuality in that connection. And I think at times I've gotten in things where it meant more to me than it did to the other person. Where I cared more than I was cared about. And that's always the risk, I think, with any kind of connection.

[00:30:17] But for some reason it's been in my life a lot more and people will just drop me or discard me and I don't understand why. But it can definitely leave a mark when you go through it multiple times. Now at the same time, I don't want to fully idealize the early internet, you know? And the film actually doesn't do that either. There is stalking that happens.

[00:30:42] There's a man who was friends with Hoshi's late boyfriend and he does not just stalk her in real life. He finds things about her on the internet, doesn't he? She uses a male username in the film chat room and she talks to Haru about this because she doesn't want them to know that she's a woman. Because she knows that they will treat her differently.

[00:31:08] They might message her, sexually harass her, different things like that. She wants to be protected from it. So I'm not saying that the early internet was a utopia by any means. And I certainly know the dangers that came with those chat rooms and stuff like that. There was deception that was happening. I mean, Haru, to a certain extent, doesn't tell the full truth about his relationship with Rose, does he?

[00:31:37] He makes Hoshi think, oh, I'm having sex with Rose and all of that because he wants to make his life sound more interesting and more exciting. And I think the film also does something interesting. It also taps into the fantasy of the internet of how people, there are some people who go online and they don't want to be more themselves. They actually want to be somebody else or they want to explore a different identity or try

[00:32:07] on other identities or they want to maybe unleash a more hidden part of themselves. And I think Rose is a good example of this where she becomes hypersexual when she's online. She is like really sexual and like flirting and she comes on to Haru and she's saying all this really like wild stuff when she's in the chat room or when she's messaging with Haru.

[00:32:35] And he immediately meets her as a result of that. Like he wants to meet her and get to know her because of the sex, her sexual expression. It's a fantasy space as well. And at times people engage in that where they can explore fantasies or they can be a version of themselves that maybe they can't be in their everyday life. And so we see that as well.

[00:33:02] That already in the 90s, I don't know about, you know, the whole history of the internet, but already in the 90s there was sexual fantasy coming out, meeting strangers, sexting, maybe like the origins of sexting here, what's happening with like Rose at times. It's not all like wholesome. So I think Marita gets into all different aspects of the early internet. He's not just saying that it's perfect and utopian, right?

[00:33:32] And we're more honest about ourselves or we're more true or authentic. There can be lying. There can be fantasy. There can be embellishment and all these things. There can be an exploration of identity or there can be an escape from a certain identity. Like Hoshi not wanting to reveal that she's a woman. She doesn't even reveal it to Haru at first. When they're emailing, Haru doesn't even know that he's talking to a woman.

[00:33:59] So it's a reminder to us of like, when we're on these screens, you don't always know who you're talking to. Or you may think that you know who you're talking to. And it is easy to pretend to be somebody else. It is easy to put on a facade. So there's a danger to that. So the internet can be this space where we try on different versions of ourselves at times. Even Hoshi herself kind of uses the internet in that way.

[00:34:28] She lives really far away from Tokyo and she cannot go and see the films that she wants to see. And I think at one time she kind of lies or something and says that she went to a film when she didn't. This is when she's talking to Haru. And Haru like goes to that movie theater and he's like, it looked very different than what you described. At times she wants to project a certain image of herself.

[00:34:53] She is someone who engages in fantasy through film and she loves watching film. She loves reading film magazines. She likes going online and inhabiting another world. She's a dreamer. And she even mentions like, I think Rear Window at one time where she says that she likes to watch other people. Film is sort of the ultimate voyeurism, particularly back in the 90s. Now I think social media has become a really intense form of voyeurism.

[00:35:24] Watching other people's lives constantly. But particularly in the 90s, film was a way to explore other people's lives. Hoshi is very invested in that. One thing that I loved about the emails and the way that Morita shows them in the film is at times he will just show them against like a blue background. But then other times he will show them against like a, there's this one scene in the film, it might be early on.

[00:35:54] At times he'll show the chat room discussions. You will see the words against a background of like a social gathering. Visually we'll see restaurants and busy streets and all of that. And then on top of that will be laid the text in the chat room and people chatting with each other about some film or whatever. What he sets up visually is this idea that just as people gather in restaurants

[00:36:22] and different places, they are also starting to gather digitally. And we didn't really have a language for that. I think we still don't have a language for it now of what it means to not just gather physically in the same space together, but to gather online where we can't see each other face to face. We can't even touch each other and we may not even fully know who we are talking to,

[00:36:48] but we are just as affected by the digital space as we are by the physical space. That's ultimately what this film is also exploring is how the digital influences and changes the physical world. I feel like Morita understood this even in 1996. Maybe he was prophetic or prescient in this way where he understood that it's not always just contained online.

[00:37:18] Like Haru and Hoshi are affected by each other. When Hoshi stops responding to Haru's messages, he's affected by that. He keeps emailing her for a while and he keeps reaching out because he has come to care about her. But what does it mean to care about someone you've never even seen? What does it mean to care about somebody who only exists on a screen as words and language? What are you attached to? What are you connecting to?

[00:37:47] Well, we don't have the language for that, but we feel it. We feel the power of it. We feel affected by it. We can even feel changed by it. Some of the people I leaned on as my mother was dying were friends that I had online who I sent voice messages to as I was sobbing in the hospital when my mom got a diagnosis that she had terminal cancer. And I was sending voice notes to my, you know, to those friends.

[00:38:14] And that is what was helping me when I was at the hospital for a week sleeping on the recliner by my mother's bed. Like we can't say it doesn't matter. It doesn't mean at times, though, that we're in connections where it matters in the same way to the other person. But it can profoundly matter these connections to other people. We can't say anymore that the Internet isn't real when it is. It has real life consequences.

[00:38:42] But we still don't know how to talk about it. And we don't know how to talk about what it means to to care about another person on the Internet or to connect to another person on the Internet. And maybe that doesn't happen for everybody. But it has happened for me. And those friendships are just as real to me as anything else. Because it's about, I think what Marita understood is that was about the one-on-one human connection. Now we go online and we're bombarded with people all day.

[00:39:10] If you go through a feed and you're watching short form video, you could see, I mean, depending on how long you're doing it, you could see hundreds of strangers on your screen all day. Or you could talk to lots of strangers on a forum or whatever. But are you really connected? I don't know. Is that real connection to see hundreds of videos every day of people that you don't know? And this film is the opposite of that. It's two people one-on-one who have become special to each other.

[00:39:39] They are concentrating on each other. And they're invested in each other. Like, it was fascinating to me when they did the bullet train and they glimpsed one another. When Haru's on the bullet train and Hoshi is in the field with the camcorder, that moment feels so enormous. Like, it's, they are so excited and happy to see each other. To just get a glimpse of each other. They don't even see each other clearly in the videos.

[00:40:09] I was just amazed by it. I was like, it's nothing like that now. Now we have such easy access to one another through the internet that one person would not be that special. Seeing a person from far away that you've emailed with would not be this enormous event. But it is in the film. That's what's so moving about it. It's like these two people have become so important to each other's lives. It's just harder to find that now. I do believe that.

[00:40:38] Doesn't mean that it doesn't exist. It's just harder to find. But it hasn't vanished. And I did want to say that in the course of my research, I learned that Merida was interested in the work of a media theorist named Marshall McLuhan. And he actually had copies of McLuhan's books, including The Gutenberg Galaxy and Understanding Media. And McLuhan is really famous for the saying, the medium is the message.

[00:41:06] And I did want to linger on that for a moment. And what I take from that in the context of Haru is that the technology itself changes the nature of the relationship between these two people. It's not simply that these two people are having an ordinary conversation that happens to be transmitted electronically. And that it would just be like a normal conversation, right, that you'd have in real life.

[00:41:32] The conversation itself, the way they talk to each other is mediated by emailing and by the computer. So by that I mean they're communicating through usernames. They're in a chat room where they're faceless and bodiless. There's just the words. And you would never have that without the computer. You would never have that in daily life in that way.

[00:41:57] The medium itself, the computer, allows the anonymity and the distance and time. It's a slower way. When you're right in front of somebody and you ask them something, they just respond. When you're in an email exchange, you might hear from somebody a month later, right, or a week later. The body is removed. There's more fantasy involved in it. Like your mind has to fill in the gaps.

[00:42:21] There's a lot that you don't know, but that can also facilitate a vulnerability and an openness. And I think Haru even says that at some point in the film. That because we can't see each other, we can actually be more honest with each other. More open with each other. And I tend to agree with that. I think that is one of the strengths, perhaps, of communicating through that kind of format, through language.

[00:42:48] When the body is taken out of it or you're not face-to-face with somebody, I do think that there's a different level of intimacy that comes into play. Like, for instance, I'll give you an example of what's happening recently is that more podcasts are shifting to video. A lot more people are recording themselves visually when they do their podcast. It's not like the dominant thing or the norm,

[00:43:14] but it's just becoming more popular for podcasts to be like, for people to clip, you know, create clips out of them or to just record themselves visually doing a podcast. A lot of celebrities do it, for instance. I will never do that. That will, you will never see that with Her Head in Films. I specifically do audio for a reason.

[00:43:37] Because once you introduce a camera and you're being watched or you're being captured or you're being surveilled, you change. So I believe that audio only, the way that this podcast is, it gives me anonymity and it gives me privacy. That creates the condition for the kind of emotional vulnerability and intimacy that I share on this podcast.

[00:44:03] If I were looking at a camera right now trying to say all of this, it wouldn't be the same. I would not be able to share those innermost parts of myself that I want to share in this space. So the emailing does allow there to be an intimacy and a way to share parts of the self that maybe you can't share in your daily life.

[00:44:28] It's like the stuff that you would put in a journal rather than what you say when you're talking to your boss or you're talking to an acquaintance out in the world. You're talking to the barista, right? It's kind of that type of difference. But there's also limitations to it. When you take the body out of it, you bring in uncertainty, deception, projection, not knowing exactly who the other person is. And there may become a time where you want to get beyond the screen.

[00:44:57] The point is, is that the internet shapes the relationship. It shapes the conditions of the relationship between Haru and Hoshi. And something is happening through the emails and through the digital world that would not necessarily be happening in daily life, perhaps. And I think that's what we still don't have the language for is like, what is happening?

[00:45:22] Because there's attachment, there's connection, there's care, but we're not looking at each other and there's no body present. And that is radically different from how we have connected to each other for much of human history, isn't it? The medium of the internet, the medium of the computer has created new ways that we relate to each other. And that is what Haru is getting at all the way back in 1996.

[00:45:51] I think there's a more optimistic and hopeful aspect to the film. Whereas I would argue that something like, we're all going to the World's Fair several decades later, shows a darker portrait of what the internet has become. And the way that we exist online, how it affects our daily lives and how we interact and connect with others through computers and through the internet. And so that's interesting to make note of as well.

[00:46:18] The Haru is a much more optimistic vision, I think. Whereas I think in the past few years or the past five or six years, we've definitely started to get darker portraits of the world online. And I'm sure there were some before that. I'm not like an expert. I haven't seen all of the films about it. So I wanted to linger a little bit on what does it mean to connect through a screen? And for me, this might be the deepest question that the film raises for me.

[00:46:48] So what does it mean to take the face and body out of communication and connection? And who are we when all of that is stripped away? And so Haru and Hoshi meet each other before many things are even established. They don't know each other's faces, their bodies, even their gender. Haru doesn't even know that she's a woman at first. When she reveals it, he is not upset. He doesn't feel like he's been lied to or something. He understands why she did it.

[00:47:17] And he also doesn't immediately sexualize her or come on to her or be like, well, now that I know that you're a woman, let's meet up or something like that, where he was much faster with Rose, of course. There's something more pure about their connection than what happens with Rose, right? There's something more emotional between Haru and Hoshi. And it starts with words. The words come before the body.

[00:47:45] And there's something really beautiful about that for me. I'll be honest with you. If you're a new listener, then you won't know. But, you know, I'm 37 and I've never been in a relationship and I've never dated and I've never been in like a mutual falling in love type of situation. And there's this part of me for much of my life of being online now for 15 years where there was this part of me that always kind of dreamed of maybe meeting somebody online,

[00:48:14] of meeting somebody where the words came first, where you got to know somebody through writing to them or connecting through your passions and your interests. So I guess that's also why this film resonates with me. Maybe it taps into some kind of dream on my part or like fantasy on my part of connecting with somebody that way. There is something radical about that of the words coming before the body because it's the

[00:48:44] reverse in ordinary life, isn't it? Where the body tends to come first. You see somebody, you register their attractiveness and you can register certain things about them that may be oppressive, right? Like if like being a woman for Hoshi, she feels it in the chat room where she wants to go online. She wants to escape being a woman. And there are different ways that in the real world you can be discriminated against as for

[00:49:14] your weight, for your race, for being a woman, all kinds of different things. Whereas when you go online and you don't, you're not seen or you're not perceived, there can be this feeling of maybe escape. Now that's what it used to be. Now it's videos and photos and selfies and it's, there's much more of an obsession with image and what you look like. I'm talking more about, you know, in the past.

[00:49:42] In real life, the body comes first. The body is paramount. And so think about the ways in which that may be really difficult for some people. And that would make the internet seductive or tantalizing. Oh, I can go on here and maybe I can be known for myself. Maybe my words and my thoughts and my feelings, maybe that can matter more than what I look like.

[00:50:07] Maybe I can be valued for my humor or my, my personality. And so that's what the film taps into. But it also, I think the film raises that question of what does it mean to connect to somebody through a screen? What is that process? How does it happen? How does that trust and intimacy unfold? How is it earned? What are the pitfalls of it?

[00:50:30] Because at the end, Hoshi learns that Haru was dating Rose and Rose is Hoshi's sister. Haru was telling her, oh yeah, I have sex with Rose when that's not what was happening. He was lying about that. And she was unsure of how to feel about it because she did feel something for Haru. They're not always being 100% truthful with each other. Or Haru has not always been truthful either.

[00:50:58] And I don't think that the film is necessarily saying that, well, the online version of you is the authentic version. And then the real life is fake or something like that. It's so interesting that even in 1996, as I said earlier, I don't think that the boundary between the internet and real life is rigid in Haru. I think Morita is able to show how they,

[00:51:23] how the real life and the internet are starting to become intertwined with each other because they can't stay on a screen. And that even happens with You've Got Mail, is that it cannot stay on a screen. At some point, these two people have to meet each other, particularly when it comes to a romantic bond. And so as much as we might want to escape certain parts of ourselves, we may want to escape our bodies. We may want to escape what we look like.

[00:51:53] We may want to escape the representation of ourselves that may lead to pain and rejection in our daily lives. We, I don't think we can fully escape it. At the end of the day, I think we all want to be loved for who we are. And we don't want to have to hide ourselves. We want to be able to be our full selves. And so the challenge, perhaps, for Hoshi and Haru at the end of the film, and this is what leaves it open-ended and unknown,

[00:52:21] is can they take what they've written to each other? Can they take that mysterious connection that has started to form through the ether of the internet? And can they love each other in real life? Can they be friends with each other in real life, in flesh and blood? And we don't know. The film just shows them at the train station, smiling, looking at each other.

[00:52:49] I think it's hopeful and it's optimistic. And I was sobbing by the end of the film, of course. But at some point, even though the connection happens on a screen and it is possible through a screen, even if we don't have the language for what we're feeling when we only know somebody through the internet, it's still, it's real, but it needs to be brought into the tangible world. And that can be the challenge. There are people who meet in real life

[00:53:19] and they can't, they don't have the spark that was online. And I find that really fascinating that you may meet somebody in real life who you've only known online for a long period of time and it's not the same. We, you know, we've all heard those stories with long distance relationships and then the two people meet and it's not the same. What, I mean, this goes back to the medium is the message. What is it about that medium? What is it about that computer screen that is creating an intimacy

[00:53:49] and almost creating a version of us through the screen that doesn't quite translate to real life? That's unanswered, isn't it? Of like, if you connect online and you're revealing these parts of yourself and you're being vulnerable and you're being authentic for the most part, then it really should work in real life, shouldn't it? But once you take away the computer, you take away that medium, you take away the usernames

[00:54:18] and you put the body back into it and the face and all of that, something changes. Something gets lost. And I find that really fascinating. And then there are people who can hold on to the spark and that seems to be the case with Haru and Hoshi, perhaps. And I think the internet has made me think more about identity and almost like, is there a double self that's created? For much of our lives or before the internet became what it is or before social media existed, we were just our everyday life.

[00:54:47] We were just our everyday selves. We were just the people that's in ordinary life and we see Hoshi and Haru in their everyday lives. You're Hoshi at the bakery. You're Haru at the grocery store, right? Like, or you're at the movie theater. You're going about your day and that's all you were. And you're going to work and you know, you see Hoshi with her family. Then there's Hoshi in the chat room. Then there's Hoshi through email.

[00:55:16] It's changed our relationship to identity. I'm me. I'm Caitlin in my daily life where I live. Working, reading, crocheting. And then there's me on this podcast. Although I try to express myself authentically. And then in the past, there was me on Instagram. Or there's me through email. Or there's me back on Twitter or on Tumblr.

[00:55:43] There's all these versions of Caitlin on the internet. And so there's like, there's me. And then there's the representation of myself online with people online. And what is that? It's like a double self. It feels like. It's like this other version of me that I have to contend with. And that maybe I don't even fully understand. Maybe none of us do. So you're, that's what the internet has sort of introduced into our daily lives. Is that it's, you're not just living your life.

[00:56:13] Oh, now you need to take a photo to put it on your Instagram stories. Or you need to write about this in a tweet. Or you need to put this in a sub stack post. It's this, I still don't have language for it. I got really consumed by it for a long time. Or I got wrapped up in it before I finally just extricated myself pretty much from social media. There was me living my life. And then there was me trying to represent the living of my life. Or narrate the living of my life.

[00:56:42] Or to document my life and make it legible to other people. If that makes sense. And so it's like the internet creates this double of us or something, doesn't it? Or a replication that's degraded perhaps. Like, I don't know. It's interesting to think about. Maybe that's why sometimes it doesn't work from the screen into the real world. Is that that double, that version of you is obviously not the same. I don't know.

[00:57:11] But I think the internet has like made me think more about identity, I guess, right? Just the sense of being bifurcated in some ways. And I do love how the film moves from disembodiment toward embodiment. To go from a username to the real name. To go from email and text to talking face to face. To go from the blurry camcorder images into real life, right?

[00:57:42] Standing face to face, as I said. They want to see each other through the camcorder first and then they meet because they want to confirm each other. And Hoshi says that at some point. She says, confirming your existence would help me. She wants to see him, to touch him, to know him in real life. That's sort of the ultimate validation of the friendship is that we're moving it into real life. And I want to know you fully.

[00:58:11] I want to know all of you. I don't just want to know you on a screen. I don't want to just know your words. I want to know all the parts of you, all the facets of you. I want to confirm your existence. I want us to exist with each other in the same space. I don't want you to be pixels on a screen or words on a screen. Because at first, they're blurry pixels on the camcorder footage as well. And even that is not enough. It's special. It's a beautiful moment. Two people connecting. I mean,

[00:58:40] isn't that ultimately what life is about? The singular connection with another human being. And that can happen multiple ways. Through a parent, a sibling, a friend, a lover. But at the end of the day, isn't that what life is about? That's the meaning of life. That's what makes life worth living. That real connection with another person that you have invested in. That you take the time to nurture. And I just love after the scene

[00:59:10] with the camcorders and all that where they finally get a glimpse of each other. I love when Hoshi writes later that she'll treasure the video. Whenever she says something like, whenever I'm lonely or in pain, I'll take a look at you rushing by. I just, Hoshi doesn't have a lot of friends. We see it in the film. Like, she's almost always alone. And she has a very solitary life. She almost gets engaged to a man, but it doesn't really work. And we know that

[00:59:39] her high school boyfriend has died. And that's something I'll talk about in a little bit. She's a solitary woman. Solitary figure. She watches other people's lives through film. Kind of loses herself in those fantasies. She's a dreamer, as I said. She says that she will treasure that video. It's just like, so moving to me. This connection between these two people. And we come to realize as the film unfolds, how important that connection is

[01:00:08] for Hoshi. And part, it's part of her healing. It's part of her reconnection to life after loss. And I think it says a lot about Hoshi and Haru as well, but particularly Hoshi, that her heart is still open in this way. That she can connect to Haru through a screen, through those messages. That she can care about another person, even though she cannot see them. Because the thing is, is like, why does it matter so much

[01:00:38] what somebody looks like or seeing them? Can we not care about each other just because it's another human being on the end of the screen or the end of the phone? Right? Like, I think it says a lot about her empathy and her ability to care and connect. She doesn't have to necessarily see what Haru looks like. Like, what Haru looks like is the least interesting thing about him or the least interesting part about him. That there are things that are more important than that.

[01:01:07] I'm not saying that it doesn't matter at all. Of course, you know, we want to be attracted to somebody if we're going to be in a relationship with them. And I would never say that it shouldn't matter or something like that. I'm saying, I think for Hoshi, it's just not the central thing. And she's able to care about, they're able to care about each other irrespective of that for much of the film. So what does it mean to connect through a screen?

[01:01:36] And then what does it mean to take something that blossomed on a screen and then try to plant it or replant it in real life? And what will happen between these two people now that they've met face-to-face and they are real to each other? They were real to each other the whole time, but now they're real in a different way, aren't they? The film doesn't resolve that, but it leaves us with a really beautiful ending and it puts them in the same physical world together. They never would have

[01:02:06] met each other otherwise. I always think that's an interesting part of the internet and what made it so exciting at first is that you could connect to somebody in another part of the world. We didn't have access to that decades ago. It is pretty amazing that you can connect to somebody in another country and learn about them and see their lives. I'm not saying the internet is all bad and terrible. That is a really beautiful thing. You would watch travel shows or, you know,

[01:02:36] you'd watch documentaries to learn about other people or whatever, but to directly talk to somebody. I mean, maybe you'd do like a pen pal thing when you were in school and you could write to people, but to have that kind of access to somebody in another country or who lives a totally different life from you on the other side of the world, that was unique. And with Hoshi and Haru, you know, Haru lives in Tokyo and then Hoshi lives elsewhere. They would not

[01:03:05] have crossed paths most likely, but through the medium of the internet, they did cross paths and they crossed paths through something they were both interested in. which was films. And because the film does not sexualize the relationship between Hoshi and Haru immediately or anything, this takes me to my next theme that I want to linger on, which is how the film explores friendship and human connection. For much of the film,

[01:03:35] it's a friendship. It is platonic. Morita does not, he doesn't sexualize things very quickly. Yeah, that happens with Rose and Haru. There's a lot of flirting and sexual banter on the part of Rose, but when Hoshi and Haru are talking, that hits an emotional register and it really does start as a friendship. And I said earlier, it's very mysterious to me and fascinating of like, how does a stranger become a friend?

[01:04:05] Like one day, you don't know somebody or just another person in the world and then the next, you talk, you share things, you share your daily life. They respond, they enter into it with you. You both get mutually invested. You both start to share and trust each other and you become curious about each other. That's such an important part of friendship and then gradually, you start to matter to each other and something that I love is that they meet

[01:04:34] through films and that's obviously very relevant to me and my passion for cinema, but I have many passions. I love music. I love literature. I love crochet. So I'm, you know, I have all kinds of different passions, but cinema is the one that I share through this podcast and it's been really important to my life. I love how film opens the door to each other, but what happens is that they barely talk about movies when they're emailing

[01:05:04] each other. Did you notice that? I mean, those of you who have watched the film, once they start emailing, it's not about the films at all. The films are just the pretext. The films open the door, but then they walk through that door into each other's lives and then the films are not as important. What matters is the daily or almost daily, you know, talking about their everyday lives and just knowing that somebody's there. I think there's something powerful about that when you message, like I can just speak

[01:05:34] from my online connections. How do you connect to somebody? How do you form a friendship through a screen? I think you do it through consistent care and curiosity and mutual investment. There has to be full mutuality and there's something powerful about being able to message somebody and know that they will be there, that they will respond. That's a big part of it and those have been my most lasting friendships is that you're there, I can rely on you,

[01:06:03] you are dependable, you are safe, you are consistent, all of that. Like that's very, very important to me. So it starts with film and then it becomes work, relationships, loneliness, grief, change. You know, when Hoshi has to move out of her parents' house and all that stuff, it becomes those daily things that can bind you to another person. Knowing about the ins and outs

[01:06:33] of their lives, their lives, the vicissitudes, the triumphs, the pain, the grief, all of it. That's how somebody begins to matter. It's the, it's that regularity. It's that dependability and consistency and then somebody becomes part of your, your daily life or just part of your life in general in a very consistent way. And the relationship is in the emails. That is where it exists for much of the film

[01:07:03] and that's why Morita shows us those emails, shows us them talking to each other and, and we see that they care about each other. You know, when Hoshi withdraws, Haru notices that and he keeps messaging her and he doesn't give up because she matters to him and he wants to make it right. He doesn't just let her disappear. He doesn't just throw his hands up and say, well, I guess that's over. She matters to him and he lets her know that. He displays it.

[01:07:32] He demonstrates it. He lets her know this matters to me. He's not stalking her, right? He's not badgering her or something. And he, it's not about entitlement or something like that. It's about we've known each other this amount of time and this matters to me. I'm not just going to give up and I'm not going to just like stop trying. He is risking vulnerability when he does that but he's also showing that the connection mattered to him

[01:08:02] and that it was meaningful to him and they both value that connection. They're both invested in it. They notice each other's absence. They notice when emails are not replied to. Hoshi is very vulnerable when she says, I'll treasure this video. Like she's very communicative about like this matters to me. You matter to me. And I actually don't believe that online connection is inherently less than

[01:08:30] or that it is inferior to more embodied everyday connection. It's different. I don't know if we can put it on the same level necessarily, right? It's not the same as sitting by somebody's hospital bed. I know that but I also don't think that it should be completely dismissed or diminished because the way I see it is that you can be in a room full of people and feel totally alone and you can write to somebody or text somebody

[01:08:59] or send a voice note, right? Or email somebody who you've known for a considerable amount of time or you feel a connection to or you have lots of things in common with and you can write to or share with and you can feel understood and seen and known in a way that you do not feel in your daily life. I do believe that. I really do and maybe some people don't or they think it's silly but I've experienced it and I've lived it. I've been in rooms with people and felt totally alone and then I've, you know,

[01:09:29] talked to somebody online and I felt like maybe I'm not completely alone in the world. I do think it's possible to connect with each other. I hope that maybe I know this podcast when people are listening to me I know it's one-sided. I know it's only going one way but I do hope that through my words and the things that I say I do hope that that diminishes somebody's loneliness. I do think that the internet can be used for good things and to connect to each other or to reduce

[01:09:59] the loneliness that we feel and it's sad to me that social media has now become a place where we actually feel more alone. We actually feel more disconnected and more alienated. Like I said, it's been a grieving process for me personally. A lot of people are in families where they feel like they're not understood or cared about. So for some people, some people are disabled, right? And they can't go out certain places and so the internet

[01:10:27] becomes an alternative space to try to find some kind of connection. It may not be exactly the same but we need all forms of it and this film does not say or show that connecting online through a chat room and through email is inherently inferior or not important. I would say the film actually does the opposite. It shows how profoundly important it can be. Hoshi has men

[01:10:57] pursuing her in her daily life but she feels nothing for them whereas when she's talking to Haru and has that emotional connection that's more real to her. He stirs something in her. There's something powerful about being stirred by another person and I think that's what she feels with Haru and Haru and Hoshi don't treat the connection as inferior. They don't treat it as disposable. That's very important as well. They say to each other

[01:11:26] your messages matter to me you've helped me I will treasure this video of you I will treasure these memories of you I mean that's very beautiful isn't it? Almost feels radical to me like that kind of care and intimacy and it matters it matters to try to make another person feel less alone right? Like that matters and that's what they offer to each other and so the last thing that I want to talk about for this episode and it may be

[01:11:56] the emotional heart of the film or the emotional center of the film is that this is a film about the internet and it's a film about friendship and it's a film about alternative forms of connection perhaps through a screen but it's also about a young woman who is grieving Hoshi lost her high school boyfriend and we don't immediately know that in the film it's hinted at but we only learn more about it as the

[01:12:25] film unfolds so this is a film about a grieving woman trying to reconnect to life Hoshi's solitude and her distance I think from others and from the world is partly because of the grief and the loss isn't it and she didn't just lose her high school boyfriend she also lost her mother when she was very young so she had a lonely childhood her father wasn't around very much she shares that as well

[01:12:55] and her boyfriend died in a car accident we learn and she says in the film she says I couldn't forget him I kept asking myself why go on living so this is someone who's gone through intense loss in her life and feels very destabilized by the loss of this man that she loved she's trying to go on isn't she but there's a loneliness and a sadness about her and I think that her grief explains some of what she does in the film

[01:13:25] she takes on different jobs she works at a department store then she works at a bakery she says that she enjoys working different jobs that she wants to do that it kind of makes her feel like she's in a movie she moves out of her family home she likes getting lost in fantasy and watching films and watching other people's lives doesn't she but there's there's this sense that she's not settled there's something unsettled about Hoshi that she's still trying to find herself

[01:13:54] as cliche as that sounds but she is she's trying to figure out who do I want to be and she's trying on different identities and you could even argue that when she goes in the chat room and she pretends to be a man that she's exploring different ways of being and through films she can imagine other ways of living as well and at one point she says in the film I want to be with a man who will help me bury my memories this is a

[01:14:24] really interesting part of the film for me as it goes on where Hoshi really wants to forget the loss she wants to forget her late boyfriend she wants to live again she wants to live fully she doesn't want to be buried in that grief and I think this explains also why she doesn't take the proposal from the man later on in the film who's also lost his partner lost a woman that he loved

[01:14:53] I don't believe that she actually wants to be with somebody who shares her wound I think she wants a new life I think this also explains going to different jobs and trying on different identities and stuff she wants a new life and like she says she wants somebody to help her bury those memories she really wants to live again doesn't want to live in the past and she's looking for somebody who can give her new possibilities

[01:15:23] right who excites her and stirs her that's the sense that I get she wants new memories new feelings she wants passion and possibility and also when that man proposes to her and they've both lost somebody and they share grief sharing grief is not the same thing as connection somebody can have a similar loss as you but that doesn't mean that they're right for you it doesn't mean that you can connect with each other Haru does not

[01:15:52] share that wound but she feels more about him she feels more connected to him and I think he gives her the possibility of rising out of the pain of the past she needs more than just someone who understands what she went through she wants someone who makes her feel alive again so when Haru enters her life unexpectedly I think he comes to represent that to her it's not something that she planned on or that she was even looking for

[01:16:22] she's just in the chat room and they start emailing she reached out to him and initiated it and it started to grow organically and that's the those are the best connections I believe the connections that are not forced but that they organically unfold and she wasn't looking and yet she found it and that's always I think the the most beautiful thing she even tells one of the men who's pursuing her I can't remember if it's the one stalking her or the

[01:16:52] the man who proposes to her but she says something like I met a nice guy who helps me forget about him that's what she wants she wants to feel alive again and I don't think the film is saying that she's forgetting her her late boyfriend I don't think it's saying that the grief ends now that she has met Haru I think it's more of a film about opening yourself up to love opening yourself up reconnecting to life again through a connection with another

[01:17:21] person a connection that she didn't plan and that she didn't know what even happened or didn't even know was possible it's not about erasing him it's about creating space for the presence of another person and that would be Haru right someone who makes her excited again she looks forward to his emails she wants to tell him about her day she misses talking to him right she treasures the video of him that's such a beautiful thing for somebody who

[01:17:51] has lost people who might feel like what is the point of living what's the point of going on without this person that I love and it can be very beautiful to meet somebody who reminds you that life is worth living and life is possible and good things are possible someone who excites you and stirs you and makes you feel alive and I feel like that's what Hoshi finds in Haru and it's emotional and it starts from a place of

[01:18:21] like genuine connection it's not based on what she looks like or anything like that it doesn't hurt I mean obviously she's beautiful but it's not the central part of the connection between the two of them she feels seen by him she feels understood by him and her connection with him her emotional she even says it she says that reading and writing the emails helped her recover little by little Haru has appeared and he didn't mean to he wasn't

[01:18:51] setting out to help her through her grief he wasn't trying to help her recover but by being kind to her and and being there for her reading her messages he restores something in her because of what she feels for him that's why connection is so important it reminds us that we're still capable of feeling more than just sadness and grief that's all you're capable of just like

[01:19:20] depressed in despair not wanting to to be here wondering what the point of life is and when you deeply connect to another person it's this reminder of like oh I am capable of joy I am capable of happiness I am capable of feeling something for another person and she even thanks him doesn't she she thanks him at one point and and and says I need you you're the one that

[01:19:50] I want to understand me now the subtitles that I read in my version of the film may not be exact or may not be the subtitles in a version of the film that you may watch however you find the film but isn't that beautiful I do believe in connection I've been through a lot of pain my mother's death has been very hard for me and I lost my father when I was a teenager so I've been through a lot of loss and grief I haven't had a lot of like support in the wake of my

[01:20:20] mother's death and it's been very lonely and I just couldn't be in spaces where I wasn't going to receive care and support but I do believe in connection it's been a heartbreaking time for me but I do believe that

[01:20:50] connection can restore us and can save us and I don't mean just romantic connection I mean platonic I mean friendship I believe that friendship absolutely is life saving and that's what much of this film is about it's about a friendship not a romantic relationship necessarily it is about two people who start as friends it may become more eventually and I'm sure there are those feelings and we can tell near the end when Hoshi

[01:21:20] learns about Rose her sister being with Haru that Hoshi has a lot of complicated feelings about that and that might acknowledge so I'm not saying there's not attraction or there's not that part of it or romance but it does start as something kind and wholesome and caring and emotional right and vulnerable these emails with

[01:21:50] Haru bring her back toward life and I think the film raises the question of how can another person help return us to life and that's why connection is so important is that you can go through a really painful loss and you feel like life is over and then you meet somebody and it's mysterious and you don't always know how these people come into your life and you're not always looking for it and you can't plan for it and you can't force it but when somebody

[01:22:19] arrives and they're kind and they're good and you connect it can absolutely save your life whether it's a friendship or romantic bond and she's excited again she's excited about somebody she's excited about life and that is such a beautiful and hopeful part of this film because it could have just been two people connecting through a chat room and they just had ordinary lives and neither one of them went through anything painful or difficult but I do think that part of

[01:22:49] Hoshi's story brings something really powerful to it and it shows the stakes of it and that this is more than just talking through a chat room or talking through email this is part of her healing it's part of her recovery it's part of the restoration of her the film is

[01:23:19] that I have felt like Hoshi that life was finished that not much is possible anymore how can I live without this person without my mother without my parents it's just really beautiful to think but you don't know who you could meet and you don't know what more could happen in your life Hoshi thought that her life was over and then somebody new came along somebody new appeared he doesn't erase her grief he awakens something alongside it and there's a space that

[01:23:49] Hoshi creates that Haru comes to fill and he shows her what she's still capable of love and care and attachment and curiosity and of being moved and being stirred by another person and opening your heart to that person I I'm coming to Tokyo and I want to see you and all of that and she wants that she takes that

[01:24:19] risk after having her heart broken by loss she says I want this and so the film shows us how somebody can reattach to life and reattach to other people and they get off that train and they're holding their floppy discs such a stand there and it's like the film doesn't promise us anything doesn't promise us marriage or romance or

[01:24:48] happily ever after but it says what does it mean to take that step and to take that chance and to take that risk and to step off the train and to step off the screen to move it off the screen to no longer have that barrier and to come face to face to a screen what does it mean to do that and the bravery that it takes and the risk that it takes to care

[01:25:18] about someone to bond to get attached to create a love to love and to is like such a

[01:25:48] this is a film that wears its heart on its sleeve I guess you could say right it's hopeful it's optimistic it believes in love it believes in connection and my melancholy soul my sad depressed grief stricken melancholy soul needed that right now you know I needed that reminder that connection is possible life is possible and they're standing in front of

[01:26:18] each other and the film seems to ask now what will you do you're here you're in the same space you've sent all these emails what comes next and you can imagine for yourself what might come next she leaves her isolation she leaves maybe even her grief that would have kept her in the past she leaves her fantasies and her imagination she leaves the screen they both leave the screen and are face to face with each other they're in presence in relationship

[01:26:48] real relationship with each other and that's where the possibilities live bringing it into the embodiment and we see a woman reattaching to life a woman opening up to the possibility of being affected by another person again and what bravery that is for her she's taking the risk more I think because of what she's lost and she wants to love again and she wants to care again and I do think that I needed to see that right now and I was

[01:27:35] I I I can do do see